Not all fantasy films soar with the wings of dragons or shine with the polish of Hollywood gold. Some stumble through their quests in poorly stitched cloaks, tripping over clunky dialogue and rubber monster suits. But hidden within these cinematic misfires lies a peculiar kind of magic—an alchemy of earnest ambition, chaotic creativity, and unintentional comedy that transforms failure into a form of joy.
These are the movies that make you laugh when you’re supposed to gasp, that swing swords of cardboard and summon gods from fog machines. They’re full of oddball charm, janky special effects, and plots so bonkers they circle back to brilliance. Whether born of budget constraints, overzealous direction, or misguided passion, each one holds a special place in the hearts of fantasy lovers who appreciate beauty in the bizarre.
This isn’t a list of the best fantasy films—far from it. It’s a love letter to the gloriously bad, the tragically ambitious, and the unintentionally iconic. So grab your magic staff (or remote control), and prepare to journey through twenty fantasy disasters you’ll secretly, or maybe not-so-secretly, adore.
1. Dungeons & Dragons (2000)
This chaotic adaptation of the beloved tabletop game is an overstuffed dungeon crawl of absurd dialogue, nonsensical plotting, and deeply unfortunate performances. Jeremy Irons devours scenery like he’s starving, while the rest of the cast flail wildly through a sea of digital goblins and rubber prosthetics. The CGI looks more like a PlayStation 1 cutscene than a feature film, and the tone swings from slapstick to epic without warning. Yet, despite everything, there’s something undeniably watchable here. The film tries—really tries—to capture the feeling of a D&D session gone off the rails. Every baffling decision feels like the cinematic version of a failed dice roll. You’ll laugh, you’ll cringe, and you might even roll for nostalgia.
2. Krull (1983)
Krull is what happens when you mix a fairy tale with a space opera and sprinkle it all with early-80s weirdness. The plot makes about as much sense as a dream you barely remember, involving a kidnapped princess, a reluctant hero, and a five-bladed throwing star called the Glaive. The special effects are dated, the pacing is glacial, and yet the film is oddly compelling. It brims with a sincerity that many high-gloss fantasies lack. The world-building is unexpectedly deep, with cyclopean seers and shape-shifting beasts. Sure, the dialogue is clunky and the costumes look like they’re made of painted foam, but there’s a charm in how seriously it takes itself. For many, Krull is a childhood fever dream that never quite fades.
3. The Sword and the Sorcerer (1982)
This sword-and-sorcery romp is pure 1980s pulp, complete with blood-drenched battles, damsels in distress, and a hero with a ridiculous triple-bladed sword. It’s not trying to be clever—it’s trying to be cool, and failing gloriously. The acting is uneven, the set design chaotic, and the story feels like it was made up as they went along. Yet, there’s an undeniable energy coursing through the film. It has that unmistakable drive of filmmakers who were having fun, budget be damned. If you squint, you can almost see the comic book panels it wishes it sprang from. This is a cult classic born from sheer audacity.
4. Highlander II: The Quickening (1991)
No sequel has baffled fans quite like Highlander II, which takes a fantasy about immortals and turns it into a sci-fi mess involving aliens and an ozone layer war. It’s incoherent, self-contradictory, and widely reviled—yet it has a hypnotic quality. Christopher Lambert and Sean Connery return with all the grace of confused actors collecting a paycheck. The visuals swing between beautiful and grotesque, and the story… well, it exists. Still, it’s a prime example of a movie that is so bad, you keep watching to see what it messes up next. There’s something admirable in its total abandonment of logic. The movie’s a trainwreck, but one pulled by a flying space barge.
5. Masters of the Universe (1987)
In this campy mess of a movie, He-Man trades the fantastical world of Eternia for… New Jersey. Yes, it’s a fish-out-of-water story where magic meets mall food, and it’s as weird as it sounds. Dolph Lundgren looks the part but barely speaks, while Frank Langella goes all-in as Skeletor in a performance that’s far too good for the movie. The costumes are rubbery, the dialogue clunky, and the action confusing. Still, there’s an earnest energy to the production that makes it hard to hate. It’s colorful, loud, and filled with unintentional laughs. Somehow, it endures as a cult favorite.
6. Conan the Destroyer (1984)
While its predecessor is a gritty and muscular classic, Conan the Destroyer veers into goofy territory with a more family-friendly tone and a less cohesive story. Arnold Schwarzenegger still slices his way through enemies with charisma and brute force, but the film’s lighter tone strips away some of the original’s raw intensity. It’s packed with bizarre set pieces, clumsy fight choreography, and mystifying character choices. Grace Jones as Zula is a chaotic delight, and the entire film plays like a Dungeons & Dragons campaign that derailed by hour two. The dialogue teeters between poetic and laughably wooden. The special effects are cartoonish, but the film wears its flaws like armor. It’s cheesy, overblown, and totally watchable.
7. Red Sonja (1985)
Red Sonja tries to ride the coattails of Conan but ends up as a wooden knockoff that’s unintentionally hilarious. Brigitte Nielsen’s stoic performance clashes with the campy tone, and Arnold Schwarzenegger, playing a Conan-like character, looks like he’s not sure what movie he’s in. The plot involves magical talismans, evil queens, and kidnapped children—but don’t worry if you miss the details; the movie doesn’t care either. Sword fights look more like rehearsals, and dialogue lands with the grace of a falling anvil. Yet it’s hard not to enjoy the sheer audacity of it all. It’s colorful, noisy, and weirdly hypnotic in its incompetence. Like a bad stage play, it’s fun because everyone’s trying so hard.
8. The NeverEnding Story II: The Next Chapter (1990)
Following up on the beloved original, The NeverEnding Story II trades wonder for awkward pacing and questionable storytelling. Jonathan Brandis takes over as Bastian, but the emotional weight of the first film is largely missing. The new creatures and worlds lack the imaginative spark that made the original soar. Even the beloved Falkor feels more like a puppet and less like a magical luckdragon. The villain’s plot—erasing memories—is more confusing than threatening. Still, for ‘90s kids, there’s a nostalgic charm that’s hard to shake. It’s not a good movie, but it might just be a comforting one.
9. Beastmaster 2: Through the Portal of Time (1991)
In this sequel, the loincloth-clad Dar leaves his sword-and-sand setting to chase an evil sorcerer through a time portal to modern-day Los Angeles. It’s exactly as ridiculous as it sounds, with fish-out-of-water jokes, car chases, and magic in shopping malls. The tone is wildly inconsistent, and the acting doesn’t help, but it leans into the absurdity with gusto. Marc Singer plays Dar with total sincerity, which only makes the madness more enjoyable. The animal companions are back, offering perhaps the most grounded performances in the film. It’s the kind of movie that makes you ask “Why?”—but also “Why not?” With enough popcorn, it’s a fun ride through cinematic nonsense.
10. Willow (1988)
Willow isn’t truly terrible, but it walks the line between underdog classic and oddball misfire. Directed by Ron Howard and written by George Lucas, it’s a strange alchemy of earnest fantasy, awkward pacing, and groundbreaking-for-its-time effects. Warwick Davis brings heart to the title role, while Val Kilmer’s Madmartigan steals scenes with chaotic charm. The villainous Queen Bavmorda is gloriously over-the-top, and the plot is a patchwork of better fantasy stories. It’s a movie full of heart but short on polish. Some moments are genuinely magical; others are laugh-out-loud silly. It’s a flawed gem that found love in the arms of fantasy fans.
11. Legend (1985)
Ridley Scott’s Legend is a visually stunning fever dream that pairs unicorns and fairies with murky storytelling and awkward pacing. Tom Cruise, in his early career, plays a forest-dwelling hero opposite Mia Sara and a devilishly brilliant Tim Curry as Darkness. The film looks like a fantasy painting brought to life, but the narrative is often lost in a fog of glitter and synth music. Dialogue is minimal or nonsensical, and yet every frame is dripping with mood and symbolism. The theatrical and director’s cuts differ dramatically, with fans arguing over which is better—or at least more coherent. It’s more about the experience than the story, a dream you don’t understand but can’t look away from. Despite its flaws, Legend is unforgettable in both its ambition and its surreal oddity.
12. Clash of the Titans (1981)
With its stop-motion monsters and mythological mayhem, Clash of the Titans is a charming artifact of fantasy cinema’s past. Ray Harryhausen’s creatures steal the show, from the terrifying Medusa to the lumbering Kraken. The human actors, however, often feel like props beside their animated co-stars. Dialogue is stilted, and the pacing feels like trudging through molasses, but the film’s heart is in the right place. It captures the feel of ancient myth told around a fire, even if the flames flicker a little too slowly. There’s a quaintness to its effects and earnestness to its tone that’s hard to resist. It’s a classic example of imagination outrunning execution.
13. Hawk the Slayer (1980)
Hawk the Slayer feels like a tabletop RPG brought to life by enthusiastic amateurs with a fog machine and a synthesizer. The film stars Jack Palance as an evil sorcerer and John Terry as the titular Hawk, who wields a magic sword and a grim expression. Its sets are hilariously low-budget, looking like community theater stages lit for drama class. The film’s saving grace is its utter commitment to the genre, even as it collapses under its own melodrama. The dialogue is absurdly serious, which makes it even funnier. It tries so hard to be epic that it wraps back around to being entertaining. Fans of ‘so-bad-it’s-good’ cinema consider it sacred.
14. Eragon (2006)
Hopes were high for Eragon, the adaptation of Christopher Paolini’s bestselling novel—but the end result is a flat, formulaic mess. The plot borrows heavily from Star Wars and The Lord of the Rings, but without the character depth or world-building finesse. The CGI dragon, voiced by Rachel Weisz, is a highlight, but everything else feels rushed and generic. Performances are stiff, the script uninspired, and the film ends just as it starts to get interesting. It’s the kind of movie that feels like a trailer for a better one. And yet, fans of the book and lovers of dragons still return to it. It’s a fascinating case of missed potential and earnest ambition.
15. The Black Cauldron (1985)
Disney’s The Black Cauldron was their attempt at a darker, more mature animated film—and it terrified children everywhere. Loosely based on Lloyd Alexander’s Chronicles of Prydain, the story follows a young pig-keeper battling an undead army. The animation is beautiful and shadowy, but the tone wavers wildly between lighthearted and grim. The film’s villain, the Horned King, is pure nightmare fuel, especially for younger audiences expecting a cheerful Disney outing. Critics panned it, and it nearly tanked the studio, but it gained cult status over the years. There’s something bold about its darkness, even if it doesn’t quite stick the landing. It’s Disney’s oddest duck, but an intriguing one.
16. The Adventures of Hercules (1985)
The Adventures of Hercules is a low-budget sequel that throws mythology out the window in favor of lasers, glowing orbs, and gods who wrestle in outer space. The film’s effects look like they were borrowed from a discarded sci-fi TV pilot, and the dialogue ranges from wooden to unintelligible. The plot, such as it is, involves Zeus’s thunder stolen by rogue gods and Hercules retrieving it in ways that defy logic and gravity. Ferrigno gives it his all, though his performance is dubbed, adding another layer of surrealism. The action sequences are gloriously clumsy, often using slow motion to stretch out the runtime. The audacity of combining ancient Greece with cosmic kung fu is baffling but entertaining. It’s the cinematic equivalent of a myth told by a very drunk bard.
17. Dragonheart (1996)
Dragonheart features a dragon voiced by Sean Connery, which is probably all you need to know about why it’s endearing. The film is a curious blend of heartwarming buddy adventure and baffling medieval melodrama. Dennis Quaid’s knight teams up with the last dragon to scam villages, until—surprise!—they decide to take down a tyrant. The CGI, while dated now, was impressive for the time and gave Draco a surprisingly expressive face. The tone, however, vacillates between sincere and silly, making it hard to take seriously. Still, the bond between man and beast carries unexpected emotional weight. It’s cheesy, yes, but also genuinely moving.
18. Zardoz (1974)
No list of fantastically awful fantasy films would be complete without Zardoz, a psychedelic fever dream starring Sean Connery in a red diaper, thigh-high boots, and a ponytail. Set in a dystopian future ruled by an enormous floating stone head that vomits guns, the film is a philosophical meditation wrapped in absurdity. Its plot is dense, allegorical, and barely coherent, touching on immortality, control, and existential dread. But honestly, most viewers come for the sheer weirdness and stay for the unintentional comedy. The visuals are bizarre, the tone pretentious, and the dialogue often feels like it was written by an alien who read one book. And yet, it’s unforgettable—once seen, never unseen. Zardoz is so strange that it circles back to being oddly profound.
19. Ladyhawke (1985)
Ladyhawke tells the tragic tale of two lovers cursed to be apart—he a wolf by night, she a hawk by day—destined to always miss each other. It’s a hauntingly romantic premise marred by baffling creative decisions, particularly the wildly anachronistic synth-rock soundtrack that plays over sweeping medieval vistas. Rutger Hauer and Michelle Pfeiffer are perfectly cast, and Matthew Broderick provides comic relief, but their performances often feel like they’re in different movies. The pacing drags in places, and the tone swings from dramatic to goofy without warning. Still, the love story is strangely compelling, and the cinematography lends it a dreamlike beauty. It’s flawed, yes, but emotionally resonant. Over the years, it’s won over viewers with its sincerity and odd charm.
20. Your Highness (2011)
Your Highness is a raunchy fantasy spoof that tries to blend epic adventure with stoner comedy—and mostly just confuses the two. Danny McBride plays a crude, cowardly prince alongside James Franco’s straight-faced heroic brother, with Natalie Portman as the surprisingly deadly love interest. The jokes swing wildly between absurd and juvenile, and the film never quite nails the balance between parody and homage. Special effects are surprisingly decent, and the costumes and world-building are more detailed than they deserve to be. But it’s the film’s total commitment to its vulgar tone that makes it oddly memorable. It’s not clever, but it is weirdly watchable.
Leave a comment