Time has a funny way of reshaping our perspective, especially when it comes to movies we grew up watching. Many of the children’s films that defined generations in the ’70s, ’80s, and ’90s were stamped with the family-friendly PG rating, assuring parents they were suitable for young audiences. But fast forward to today, and those same movies might raise some serious questions under modern content guidelines.
From terrifying creatures to mature themes and surprisingly edgy humor, these films often walked a tightrope between whimsy and shock. The Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) didn’t introduce the PG-13 rating until 1984, meaning that many films teetering on the edge of inappropriateness for children were lumped into the PG category. It was a different era, with looser standards and far less parental oversight about what kids could handle emotionally and psychologically.
Now, with contemporary sensibilities and a more cautious rating system, several once-celebrated PG-rated children’s classics would almost certainly be deemed too intense, frightening, or inappropriate. What follows is a look at twenty such films that, while still beloved by many, would likely get slapped with a PG-13—or even an R—if they were released today. Prepare to revisit your childhood… but maybe with the lights on.
1. Return to Oz (1985)
Gone was the technicolor cheer of Dorothy’s original journey—this dark, strange sequel threw audiences into an unsettling vision of Oz. Electroshock therapy, crumbling ruins, and the terrifying Wheelers created a dystopian landscape more suited for a horror film than a children’s fantasy. Kids in theaters were blindsided by a narrative that felt more nightmare than fairy tale. Characters like Princess Mombi, who kept interchangeable heads in cabinets, added a grotesque element few expected. It tackled mental illness and trauma in ways that would earn it serious scrutiny today. The tone was unrelentingly eerie, making viewers question if they’d wandered into the wrong movie. It remains a cult classic, but definitely not one you’d show a six-year-old without warnings.
2. The Goonies (1985)
Adventures of treasure maps and booby-trapped tunnels might sound like innocent fun—until you recall the strong profanity and threats of physical harm throughout. Sloth’s frightening appearance and the Fratellis’ violent antics offered a surprising amount of menace. Kids smoked cigarettes, shouted vulgarities, and navigated life-or-death scenarios with no adult oversight. Though the camaraderie is heartwarming, the film’s rawness stands out. Today’s PG movies typically steer clear of the kind of language and suggestiveness peppered throughout this cult hit. It’s a rollercoaster of fun and fear, with enough edge to make censors hesitate. The Goonies never say die—but modern parents might say, “not yet.”
3. Beetlejuice (1988)
Few films mix the macabre with the hilarious quite like Tim Burton’s Beetlejuice. Right from the beginning, death, suicide, and the afterlife are served up with whimsical chaos. Michael Keaton’s manic, crude title character flirts with the line between funny and downright disturbing. Sexual innuendo, violence, and moments of genuine creepiness are masked by colorful visuals and snappy dialogue. It delighted audiences but left parents puzzled by its PG rating. Today, its themes would likely land it squarely in PG-13 territory, if not higher. Beetlejuice might still be the “ghost with the most,” but his antics would come with content warnings now.
4. Gremlins (1984)
Cute at first glance, these mischievous creatures quickly turn into pint-sized terrors. Gremlins embodies chaos with scenes of violence, dark humor, and even murder, all wrapped in Christmas lights. A story that begins with a holiday gift spirals into something closer to a horror-comedy. Gremlin attacks are gruesome and mean-spirited, featuring microwaves, blenders, and fire. Spielberg’s involvement ensured widespread release, but controversy followed, helping prompt the PG-13 rating’s creation. It’s a film that traumatized many unsuspecting children with its bait-and-switch of tone. Even today, few family films would dare go this dark while still trying to sell plush toys.
5. Poltergeist (1982)
Despite being co-written and produced by Steven Spielberg, this supernatural thriller was somehow rated PG—a choice that baffles modern viewers. From corpses erupting from the ground to demonic possession, the movie delivers unrelenting fear. The image of a clown doll dragging a child under a bed haunts a generation. Its portrayal of paranormal horror was anything but subtle or child-friendly. Tension builds relentlessly, leaving little room for comic relief or softness. It set the standard for ghost stories but was far from appropriate for the playground crowd. Nowadays, its intensity would almost certainly land it in the PG-13 or R zone.
6. Watership Down (1978)
An animated film about rabbits might seem like a gentle tale for young eyes—but this adaptation is anything but serene. Themes of mortality, existential dread, and brutal violence permeate nearly every scene. Blood flows freely during animal battles, and the tone is unflinchingly bleak. Parents expecting something akin to Bambi were met with carnage and despair. It’s less a children’s movie and more a philosophical war epic wrapped in fur. Today’s animation is rarely this grim, particularly in films marketed to families. Watership Down endures as a haunting, powerful story—but decidedly not for preschoolers.
7. The Secret of NIMH (1982)
Mysticism, death, and genetic experimentation aren’t standard cartoon fare—but they form the backbone of this Don Bluth masterpiece. The animation is stunning, but the plot’s darkness runs deep. Mrs. Brisby’s quest to save her children leads her into sinister territory filled with rats conducting unethical science. Magic and science blend in a foreboding, almost gothic setting. Death is ever-present, as are themes of sacrifice and fear. With today’s expectations for lighter, sanitized kids’ content, this one would get flagged immediately. It’s a beautiful film, but emotionally heavy and decidedly not “Saturday morning” material.
8. The Black Cauldron (1985)
Disney took a daring turn with this tale of necromancy and skeletal armies. The Horned King remains one of the most terrifying villains in animation, surrounded by imagery straight from a nightmare. Darkness saturates the world, both literally and thematically. The stakes feel more adult, with death looming large and humor kept to a minimum. Audiences were shocked by its grim aesthetic and intensity. It was a box office disappointment, partly due to its tone, but later found appreciation for its boldness. In today’s market, it’d be shelved in PG-13 fantasy without a second thought.
9. The Witches (1990)
Roald Dahl’s unsettling story was faithfully adapted into a film that did not shy away from fear. Children turning into mice, grotesque transformations, and Anjelica Huston’s horrifying makeup left deep impressions. Tension and menace dominate, balanced only by brief comedic moments. It doesn’t pull punches in how it portrays danger to children. Magic here is terrifying rather than wondrous. While it fascinated many young viewers, it also gave plenty of nightmares. Its dark tone and visuals would face serious scrutiny from today’s ratings board.
10. The NeverEnding Story (1984)
Whimsy and sorrow collide in this fantasy adventure that pushed emotional boundaries. Atreyu’s journey is riddled with grief, loss, and internal struggle. The infamous death of Artax in the Swamp of Sadness remains one of cinema’s most heartbreaking moments. There’s also existential dread in the form of The Nothing, consuming the world without mercy. The story touches on depression, loneliness, and abandonment. While it’s a beautiful tale about imagination and resilience, the psychological depth is staggering for young viewers. Today, it might be deemed too emotionally intense for a PG label.
11. Labyrinth (1986)
David Bowie’s glam-rock Goblin King added a layer of surreal sensuality to this fantasy. Puppetry and set design created a whimsical world, but underlying themes of adolescence and temptation lurk. Sarah’s journey is one of self-discovery, but it walks a line that can feel unsettling. The villain’s ambiguous charm would spark discourse in a modern age. Tone swings between quirky and haunting, never fully settling. It’s imaginative, yet threaded with darker nuances. PG today would not cover this much symbolic maturity.
12. The Dark Crystal (1982)
Mystical and mythical, this Henson production leaned heavily into the eerie. Alien creatures and a plot about genocide create a stark, almost spiritual darkness. There’s little in the way of comic relief or traditional heroics. The world is haunting, not inviting, filled with decaying castles and vulture-like villains. Many children found it fascinating, while others were disturbed. It’s complex, strange, and utterly uncompromising in tone. The lack of levity places it far from today’s kid-oriented animation.
13. E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial (1982)
Though a heartwarming classic, E.T. doesn’t shy away from fear and pain. Scenes of the alien’s near-death and cold government scientists spark real distress. Swear words pepper the dialogue among the children. The emotional rollercoaster is raw and powerful, with realistic portrayals of grief and loneliness. It’s more intense than many people remember. Today, parental guidance would come with more caveats. Spielberg’s touch elevated it, but didn’t soften it.
14. Big (1988)
A child in an adult’s body sounds like harmless fun, but this film explores adult relationships in ways that feel unsettling in retrospect. Romantic tension and implied intimacy between a grown woman and a mentally 12-year-old boy would raise serious concerns today. It walks the line between whimsy and inappropriate. The wish-fulfillment angle is played sincerely, but adult life isn’t sugarcoated. There’s drinking, job stress, and sexual confusion. A comedy on the surface, it holds complicated undertones. PG-13 would be the minimum rating today.
15. Honey, I Shrunk the Kids (1989)
Massive insects, near-death experiences, and family drama are packed into this fun-sized adventure. The kids face electrocution, drowning, and monstrous scorpions. Though humorous, the danger is constant and real. It flirts with themes of parental negligence and survival. The visuals are thrilling but can be overwhelming for younger audiences. It’s action-heavy for something branded as family-friendly. Under modern standards, its tension might bump it up a notch.
16. The Indian in the Cupboard (1995)
What begins as magical discovery soon touches on violence, colonialism, and mortality. The film presents real historical trauma through miniature toys brought to life. Gun violence, cultural misunderstandings, and heavy emotional themes pepper the story. It attempts education through fantasy but risks misrepresentation. Sensitive topics are introduced but not deeply explored. Today’s cultural lens would demand more nuance. Its intentions are noble but complicated.
17. Jumanji (1995)
Chaos rules from the first drumbeat, with wild animals and deadly traps flooding into reality. Children and adults alike are thrown into violent, high-stakes situations. Giant insects, stampedes, and emotional trauma dominate the story. The pace is relentless, with little reprieve. Fear is ever-present, even through comedic beats. PG today often avoids that level of intensity. The wild ride would likely be reeled in with stricter oversight.
18. The Mask (1994)
Jim Carrey’s manic performance is a spectacle of wild energy and cartoonish violence. Beneath the surface, however, lies suggestive content and adult humor. The Mask’s behavior is often outrageous, bordering on lewd. Physical comedy includes guns, explosions, and intimidation. Sexual innuendo is frequent and bold. It thrilled kids but played heavily to adult sensibilities. In today’s climate, a higher rating would be certain.
19. Space Jam (1996)
Animated antics meet real-world stakes in this basketball-centric adventure. While beloved, it includes some eyebrow-raising jokes and suggestive moments. The tone is frenetic, occasionally overwhelming for younger viewers. Physical comedy often mimics violence. There’s an adult undertone running beneath the silliness. It’s not inappropriate, but it skates the edge. Modern guidelines might recommend a reevaluation.
20. Who Framed Roger Rabbit (1988)
An animated noir bursting with innuendo, slapstick violence, and crime, this film defies modern rating expectations. Jessica Rabbit’s overt sensuality alone would warrant caution. Murder, alcohol, and moral ambiguity make it more adult than it appears. Blending live action and animation creates a surreal, at times jarring world. It’s a brilliant film but far from juvenile. Parental guidance today would demand a second glance. There’s more going on here than meets the toon-filled eye.
Leave a comment