For every golden age of television comedy, there’s a shadowy trail of missteps—sitcoms that missed their mark, bewildered their audiences, and left critics reaching for stronger coffee. Over the past 25 years, network and streaming services alike have given us countless attempts to bottle lightning in a 22-minute laugh track. Some of them soared. Others… well, they crash-landed in unforgettable ways.
This article isn’t about schadenfreude—okay, maybe a little. It’s about honoring the bizarre, misguided, and sometimes fascinating failures of sitcom television. From baffling casting choices to tone-deaf humor to wildly miscalculated concepts, these shows serve as a reminder that the path to great comedy is paved with plenty of banana peels. Some failed due to ambition, others due to laziness, but each one left a mark—for better or (mostly) worse.
So here they are: the worst sitcom of every year from 2000 to 2025. Not every show was the absolute bottom of the ratings, and not all deserved to be hated. But for one reason or another, these 25 sitcoms represent the biggest “what were they thinking?” moments in comedy television history.
1. 2000 – Bette
A Broadway legend stepped into television hoping to bring her vibrant, outsized personality to a weekly comedy. But what played so well on stage failed to land in the rigid structure of network sitcoms. The concept revolved around a heightened version of her real life, though few elements felt grounded enough to connect with viewers. Attempts at glamor and family dynamics clashed awkwardly, and mid-season retooling—including the recasting of her on-screen daughter—only made things worse. Critics were baffled by the tonal confusion and viewers tuned out quickly. Even the star herself seemed uneasy with the constraints of the format. This short-lived experiment was Bette, and it faded as quickly as it arrived.
2. 2001 – Emeril
Emeril Lagasse revolutionized the Food Network, but his sitcom Emeril flopped harder than a soufflé in a thunderstorm. NBC took a gamble by giving a celebrity chef his own show, banking on Emeril’s “BAM!” energy to carry him into acting. Unfortunately, charisma in a kitchen didn’t translate to comedic timing on a soundstage. The scripts were awkward, the jokes forced, and the premise felt paper-thin. Critics derided the show as dull and gimmicky, and viewers simply tuned out. Only a handful of episodes aired before the network quietly cut its losses. Emeril returned to cooking, and the sitcom was quickly forgotten—except as a masterclass in what not to greenlight.
3. 2002 – The Grubbs
The Grubbs was so bad, Fox refused to even air it—an honor few sitcoms can claim. Starring Randy Quaid, the show was about a dysfunctional working-class family with no moral compass, no charm, and apparently, no funny bone. Critics who screened early episodes described it as mean-spirited and painfully unfunny. The show was accused of lacking any redeeming qualities, pushing crassness over character development. Fox pulled the series just days before its premiere, fearing audience backlash. It now lives on in infamy, cited in television circles as one of the worst sitcoms ever made—even though it never technically aired. Sometimes not airing is the kindest cut of all.
4. 2003 – Luis
Representation without nuance can backfire spectacularly. In this case, a beloved character actor was thrust into the spotlight in a sitcom that leaned heavily into broad ethnic stereotypes. Instead of delivering a fresh take on urban life and working-class struggles, it settled for recycled gags and dated punchlines. The show’s tone wavered between slapstick and awkward earnestness, rarely finding the rhythm needed for either. Even fans of the lead found it hard to sit through. Network support vanished quickly as ratings dipped. Luis was off the air in under two months.
5. 2004 – The Mullets
There’s lowbrow, and then there’s proudly caveman-level comedy—and this one aimed squarely at the latter. Focused on two brothers whose entire identities revolved around their hairstyles and their love for beer, the show tried to parody working-class life but ended up insulting it instead. There was no real story structure, no emotional anchor, just one weak punchline after another. Critics struggled to even classify it as satire. The actors leaned into the absurdity, but not even their commitment could save the writing. Viewers didn’t find it funny; they found it exhausting. The Mullets lived down to its title.
6. 2005 – Stacked
Setting a sitcom in a bookstore sounded charming—until it became clear the shelves were mostly stacked with bad jokes. This show cast a world-famous model in an effort to subvert expectations, but it couldn’t decide if it wanted to be smart or just smirking. The attempt to balance allure with slapstick fell flat, leaving both elements underdeveloped. Scenes relied on easy gags and double entendres, often sidelining the ensemble cast. Occasional glimpses of wit weren’t enough to save the storylines. Despite a splashy debut, it quickly lost viewers. Stacked never found its literary rhythm.
7. 2006 – Four Kings
A show about four lifelong friends navigating adulthood in New York felt like familiar territory, but this version brought nothing new to the table. Every plot felt like a leftover from better sitcoms, reheated without seasoning. Chemistry among the cast was uneven, and the writing couldn’t rise above tired tropes about dating and commitment. Viewers gave it a shot based on its pedigree, but tuned out once they realized there was no spark. Even network promotions couldn’t disguise the mediocrity. The cancellation came quickly and without much protest. Four Kings proved that bromance alone can’t carry a comedy.
8. 2007 – Cavemen
Sometimes a premise is so odd, it defies logic—and expectations. Expanding a popular insurance commercial into a sitcom about cavemen living in modern society seemed like a tongue-in-cheek idea. But the execution lacked the satire or self-awareness needed to make it work. The result was a surreal, uncomfortable mix of racial allegory and slapstick that pleased no one. Critics pounced on its tone-deaf approach and baffling dialogue. Audiences tuned in for the novelty and left after the pilot. Cavemen became the go-to punchline for misguided TV development.
9. 2008 – Kath & Kim (U.S. version)
Cultural imports don’t always travel well, especially when they lose the spirit of their source material. An American remake of a beloved Australian sitcom tried to mimic its predecessor’s absurdist humor but came across as shrill and empty. The quirky mother-daughter dynamic that charmed original viewers turned grating in translation. Performances were overly broad, and the chemistry was awkward rather than endearing. It failed to generate the ironic distance that made the original a cult favorite. Reviews were harsh, and ratings were worse. NBC’s Kath & Kim remake quickly found itself in the clearance bin.
10. 2009 – Hank
The return of a sitcom legend should have been cause for celebration, not concern. Tasked with portraying a high-powered executive who’s forced to downsize his life after a financial collapse, this series leaned into tired fish-out-of-water gags and toothless family drama. The lead actor’s signature wit was lost in a sea of bland jokes and awkward setups. Viewers who expected a clever comeback instead got a by-the-numbers sitcom with no bite. Even the network seemed unsure, airing only a few episodes before pulling the plug. Years later, even its star admitted the show never worked. Hank was a misstep in an otherwise storied career.
11. 2010 – $#! My Dad Says
Turning a hit Twitter feed into a primetime show was a bold move, especially when the content relied on bite-sized grumpiness rather than fully formed stories. The adaptation struggled to build a coherent world around its central figure, who came off less like a curmudgeonly sage and more like a sitcom caricature. Despite the presence of a legendary actor in the lead role, there was no rhythm to the dialogue and no heart to the supporting cast. What might’ve worked as background quips turned clunky when forced into punchlines and plotlines. Critics found it outdated, while younger audiences never connected to the generational premise. The title alone raised eyebrows—and not in a good way. $#! My Dad Says* fizzled fast and left little behind but confusion.
12. 2011 – I Hate My Teenage Daughter
The premise sounded like a modern twist on parenting comedy: two women realizing their teenage daughters had grown into the same kinds of bullies who once tormented them. But instead of heartfelt reflection or sharp satire, what unfolded was a shrill and awkward series of punchlines aimed at tired stereotypes. The lead performances tried to bring energy, but the material gave them little to work with—characters were often reduced to whining or screaming. Attempts at edginess came off as bitter, and the mother-daughter dynamics felt forced rather than funny. Each episode leaned heavily on cliché instead of character, turning real emotional potential into flat farce. Reviews were harsh across the board, with critics calling it tone-deaf and humorless.
13. 2012 – Rob
What could have been a lighthearted family sitcom quickly found itself on the defensive. Centered around a man navigating life with his new in-laws, the show tried to blend cultural comedy with traditional sitcom beats but never found its footing. Characters fell into flat stereotypes, and the dialogue rarely rose above first-draft material. Attempts to balance broad humor with warmth ended up doing neither effectively. The show lacked identity, veering wildly from one trope to another without consistency. Viewers never really warmed up to its tone or pacing. Rob, despite a well-known star, landed with a thud and disappeared almost as fast.
14. 2013 – Dads
A high-profile producer and a recognizable cast couldn’t save this series from its own worst instincts. It framed itself around two adult men dealing with their eccentric, offensive fathers—but instead of delivering irreverent charm, it settled for uncomfortable racial jokes and flat slapstick. Every opportunity for depth was skipped in favor of shock humor, most of which fell embarrassingly flat. There was little chemistry among the cast and even less wit in the writing. Critics described it as tone-deaf and soulless. Viewers were similarly unimpressed, and ratings tanked immediately. Dads remains one of the decade’s most notorious misfires.
15. 2014 – Mulaney
It’s a tough transition from stage to screen, especially for a performer used to commanding the room on his own terms. This sitcom, a passion project for a successful stand-up comic, was an earnest attempt to channel his voice into a traditional three-camera format. But the results felt stilted and self-conscious, like watching someone play themselves with the volume turned down. The supporting characters were barely developed, and the pacing never matched the energy of his live routines. Critics noted how hard it was trying to be Seinfeld without any of the finesse. Audiences drifted away after just a few episodes. Mulaney was a rare stumble from a rising comedy star.
16. 2015 – Truth Be Told
When a show attempts to tackle timely issues with humor, the writing has to be sharp and the tone carefully tuned. This one aimed for a modern reflection on race, marriage, and friendship, but often felt like it was written in a vacuum. Scenes played like awkward think pieces wrapped in sitcom setups, with characters delivering commentary rather than existing as real people. The humor rarely connected, and the social commentary came off as overly sanitized. Even the warm moments felt forced. Viewers wanted to support its ambition but couldn’t overlook its clunky execution. Truth Be Told ended quietly, largely forgotten.
17. 2016 – Crowded
The classic premise of adult children moving back in with their parents is one most audiences can relate to. But relatability didn’t make this effort resonate. The characters were drawn so broadly that their behavior often felt implausible, and the writing leaned heavily on one-liners instead of exploring real dynamics. The ensemble had decent chemistry, but the show never trusted its cast enough to slow down and let relationships grow. Instead, it churned through plot setups without substance. It was the kind of sitcom that felt assembled, not created. Crowded came and went with little fanfare and less impact.
18. 2017 – Imaginary Mary
Merging animation with live-action can be charming when handled well—but charm was exactly what this show lacked. The story revolved around a woman reconnecting with her imaginary childhood friend, but the idea was more whimsical than the show knew how to handle. The animated sidekick, rather than being lovable or funny, came off as grating and unnecessary. Emotional beats missed their mark, and the tone bounced wildly from sincere to zany without much warning. Attempts at quirk only highlighted the emptiness at its core. Reviews were lukewarm to icy, and the ratings followed suit. Imaginary Mary was quietly shelved before anyone could get attached.
19. 2018 – Living Biblically
Drawing inspiration from a best-selling memoir, this comedy wanted to explore what happens when a man decides to live by the Bible—literally. But what could have sparked thoughtful satire or warm insight instead felt like a parade of half-baked sketches. Characters were one-dimensional, and each episode revolved around gimmicky moral dilemmas rather than genuine human stakes. Religious viewers didn’t find it reverent; secular ones didn’t find it clever. The premise proved too thin to sustain even a single season. What little audience it did attract vanished quickly. Living Biblically had a short, strange run before fading from memory.
20. 2019 – Abby’s
A backyard bar, an unconventional host, and a “no phones” rule seemed like a decent pitch for a hangout comedy. But this show struggled to give its oddball setting any life beyond the concept itself. The laughs were mild, the supporting cast underwritten, and the central premise never really evolved past the pilot. Even the idea of a bar run outside the law lacked tension or consequence. It felt more like a stage play trying to be a sitcom, confined and stilted. Though it had a unique setup, it never grew into anything memorable. Abby’s closed up shop before anyone really noticed it opened.
21. 2020 – United We Fall
The setup was as familiar as it gets—parents overwhelmed by life, kids acting up, and in-laws always a step too close. What made this sitcom stand out, unfortunately, was how it brought absolutely nothing new to the formula. Characters existed mostly to tee up eye-roll-worthy punchlines, and any potential for heartfelt connection was buried under layers of tired writing. Jokes landed with a thud, and even the chemistry between leads couldn’t lift the script. It felt like a throwback in the worst way: clunky, flat, and overly sanitized. Viewers tuned out fast, and critics were no more forgiving.
22. 2021 – Call Me Kat
Reviving the fourth wall break in sitcoms can be clever, but this series leaned on the gimmick so heavily it nearly collapsed. The lead actress brought charm and warmth to her role, but the scripts rarely met her halfway. Episodes often felt like stitched-together sketches rather than coherent stories, and the humor was too inconsistent to build momentum. Attempts to create a cozy, inclusive vibe clashed with awkward pacing and scattered tone shifts. The result was a series that felt more like a missed opportunity than a failure—but a miss nonetheless. Despite a loyal fan base, ratings never took off.
23. 2022 – How We Roll
Real-life inspiration doesn’t always translate into compelling fiction. This show, based on the story of a factory worker turned professional bowler, had a built-in underdog charm—but squandered it on safe, middling storytelling. Characters were either bland or exaggerated, and the plotlines played like filler content between commercial breaks. There was sincerity in its concept, but the execution lacked the confidence or creativity to hold attention. Every episode seemed to aim for average and hit below. Viewers gave it a chance but quickly lost interest. How We Roll spun into obscurity just a few frames in.
24. 2023 – Velma
A beloved character from a classic franchise was reimagined in animated form—but almost nothing else about this series resembled the original spirit. Gone were the playful mysteries and friendly charm, replaced with biting cynicism and relentless self-commentary. It aimed to be edgy and ironic, but the writing felt more mean-spirited than clever. Fans of the original were alienated, and newcomers were confused by the tonal whiplash. Visuals were slick, but the content never settled into an identity that made sense. Critics and audiences alike were vocally disappointed. Velma became a case study in how not to reboot a legacy brand.
25. 2024 – Smoggie Queens
A fresh comedy set in a northern British town promised to highlight overlooked voices and working-class humor, but quickly fell into one-dimensional portrayals and recycled gags. It tried to ride the wave of drag-inspired television with bold style choices and campy energy, but never built the emotional foundation to support its flair. Characters were drawn as stereotypes rather than people, and episode plots often felt thrown together instead of thoughtfully structured. Some viewers appreciated the energy, but most couldn’t overlook the lazy writing and hollow punchlines. Reviews were particularly harsh from UK critics, who accused it of punching down while pretending to lift up.
26. 2025 – Adults
Set in New York and targeted at a Gen Z audience, this eight-part comedy hoped to capture the chaos and beauty of twenty-something life. What unfolded instead was a show so self-consciously modern that it forgot to be relatable or even coherent. Dialogue often sounded like tweets read aloud, and characters seemed more like archetypes than real people. Attempts at emotional vulnerability were undercut by forced edginess, and the central relationship never developed the authenticity it needed. Visually, it was polished; narratively, it was a mess. Critics noted the potential but panned the execution.
Leave a comment